After the first major tournaments on Nov/Dec our new Associate Editor, Kenan Anderson, breaks down what affirmatives are dominating the metagame and how affirmatives are, and aren't, interpreting this resolution.
The topic for today is what to make of arguments like “your interpretation X leads to Y bad thing” and the common response “but you could read theory on Y bad thing.” Bob likes the former (sometimes) but the latter never.
The 2018 November/December LD Topic is "Resolved: In a democracy, the public’s right to know ought to be valued above the right to privacy of candidates for public office."
Bob challenges the use of abbreviated arguments or "enthymemes" in contemporary kritik debate. On his view, they discourage innovation and clash, exclude debaters, and emphasize the judge's knowledge over the skill of the debaters.